Buy our new album “A Brief Crack Of Light” on CD or limited edition vinyl at Amazon.co.uk, or direct from Global Music

Martin leaves Therapy? a 3 piece

#

Started by caucasian_psychosis

You’re viewing replies 31–60 of 269 by 109 people

·

Page: First | | | Last

#31

Andy D wrote:

Damn, I’m really devestated. This is the worst break-up T? had to deal with since Fyfe left 9 years ago. Sorry to say that I felt a lot worse on that day but still.

He will be greatly missed and certainly the songs he was essential on live and that will be played very rarely from now on.

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 00:31

#32

Gav wrote:

Shit

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 01:17

#33

rocking roxy wrote:

there you are for a few days not online…and then this happens…

god damn, this news, makes me feel sad, dissapointed and angry in once, cause i simply cannot understand it.

and for me it sounds so too, ass he was kicked out…but why? what’s that for a reason? professionell and not personal ?…do they want to save money for all the flights and hotels, or what?
and to ensure a positive future??? do they think, without martin, T? will become big again???
sorry, but to me it sounds like, “we don’t need him anymore, so let’s throw him out”…and i really hope, that i’m completely wrong with that…

i think for me therapy? will be never that again, what they were with martin as he was a part of therapy?
and for me he was also a very important part!
i mean, who will do the backing vocals now…or jump in when andy’s voice is gone?
we all know, that other members are not really able to sing…
and what’s wrong with having a second guitar or having a cello???

martin, i will miss you a lot.
you are a great musician and cool guy..i hope you will do fine and become happy in the future and that you will find your way…and thanks a lot for all the great shows with you!

p.s.: just let us know, when the others treated you bad! we will kick their asses then for you ;)

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 05:26

#34

MarkoJii (Evil Twin) wrote:

This is a shocking news… Hopefully the Russian dates will be on.

I personally will miss Martin more than Fyfe and Graham because he is really nice person, I’m glad that I had a chance to talk couple times with him. Truly a really nice fellow as well the others too…

What happens now with the cello tunes on stage?

Cheers, Martin! Have a nice time and inform us all in this board about your doings. Thank you for the GREAT 9 years!!!!

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 06:44

#35

ratamahatta wrote:

FUCK

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 08:06

#36

mooneycult wrote:

A real shame this…best of luck to Martin in the future.

Even though it terrible to be talking like this already I really do think the band should consider looking for a replacement guitar player at some point in the future. Going back to a 3 piece permenantly just doesn’t strike me as a great idea…look at the Manic Street Preachers now!

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 08:35

#37

ratamahatta wrote:

well if they need a replacement, im always here!

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 08:39

#38

JSar666 wrote:

This sucks, but I’m sure the new material will rock.

If you need a replacement… etc

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 09:37

#39

Alan wrote:

It seems to me that while Martin was out with his ear problems, Andy & Michael realised they could still play as a 3 piece.

Also, splitting the profits between 3 instead of 4, and not paying costs (flights/hotels etc) of a fourth person would (maybe, just maybe) be the underlying reason why they would sack Martin.

Sacking him because of musical reasons doesn’t make sense. Martin added a lot to the live sound as well as writing a lot of his own songs and collaborating with Andy. I actually had a feeling that Martin would leave the band of his own accord, but being fired definately seems a bit strange to me.

Best of luck to Mr McC in whatever he does in the future!

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 09:42

#40

RedBullWodka wrote:

Title: Martin got kicked?

What the hell is going on???

I remember when I saw the first live appearance of the guys on the 94 EMA show in TV. That was the first time I saw Martin on stage (asking myself what this man with the weird looking cello is doing on stage)… Since then he got more & more “into the band”, he joined the tour in ‘95 and later on it was announced that he became something of a full member of TPY? And, as my opinion, it was well going all the time. Even in ‘95 Martin tried to finish the recordings of other bands and though being with TPY?. And now he’s just being kicked out???

I and all of my friends, cheers to Chaosbabe… thank you for waking me up in the middle of the night, just to bring me bad news… Cheers to wickedman … sorry for waking you up in the morning with bad news… Cheers to Lars for a never ending discussion in the middle of the night about the band.
Do I look tired today?

What a bad day, sorry guys, but to me Martin ment more than “just” a quarter of the Band.

Ina

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 09:45

#41

needsometherapy wrote:

Good Luck Martin and Thank You !!!

You will really be missed …

Please please please, can someone let us know what REALLY happened? Was it a MONEY issue, a WOMAN issue, a TALENT issue or what?

I think we deserve to know what happened. Come on T? you have always been honest. Don’t just hide behind the “personal” or “professional” reasons excuse …

Today is a sad day … When Fyfe left the future of T? was dim … But somehow they survived. When Martin got in they sounded even better (string wise) and then Neil’s arrival brought the band to a new high level !!! The Fyfe’s era was gone and part forgotten. Martin’s departure isn’t as bad as Fyfe’s one cause I think Neil is a superb drummer and as a trio T? can be very good (as proven also recently at Barfly). But Martin was an extra and was giving that extra to the whole band. Now T? are back to old good T? (nearly as good as a trio with Fyfe) but with the “extra” missing out … :(

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 10:08

#42

Distorted wrote:

best of luck in the future martin, whatever you get up to.

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 10:08

#43

Nitro (Erdem Capar) wrote:

Title: What A Day!!!

Two bad news in two days, who can stand it?

First, T? shows in Turkey delayed, second Martin left!!!

I can’t believe it!!! I prepared everything for T? shows in Turkey, now there’s nothing in my hands :((

By the way, to be honest, Graham’s departure didn’t affect me this much…

Bye bye Martin!!!

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 10:12

#44

Nausea wrote:

good luck in the future whatever you do, martin.

i loved the ‘cello-songs’.. especially on infernal love. thank you.

(but i think andy and michael made the right choice. now just find fyfe, and force him to join for one last album/tour :D ).

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 10:17

#45

Citizen Erased (confused again) wrote:

There’s obviously more going on here than either Martin or the rest of the band have so far disclosed, and hopefully that’ll change, but it does seem odd given Martin’s recent comments. Maybe it is something to do with his health, maybe the others just really liked playing as a 3-piece again, maybe there’s just no room for a cello in the new material. Which would be a shame as it never sounded forced into T?’s music, it just sounded right.

Martin is a very talented musician, and hopefully we won’t miss him, because hopefully he’ll keep playing in public in some shape or other. I will miss seeing him at T? gigs though.

Whatever you do, good luck in the future Martin, and please don’t be stranger to WoM.

And for that matter, all the best to Andy, Michael and Neil as well. Am sure you all have your reasons for the change.

CE

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 10:21

#46

superfabietto wrote:

Just now I realized what’s happened…Martin left the band!
I could even cry now!!! I hope Martin can back to his decisions, it’s all I can say!

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 10:29

#47

superfabietto wrote:

How did therapy? perform the cello songs? I can’t imagine Die Laughing, Stories, Diane with any cello! besides Therapy? are going to lose the power of the second guitar!!!
NOOOO…STOP IT YOU’RE KILLING ME!!!!

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 10:33

#48

tokaarme wrote:

Oh man.. Shitty news..

But life goes on - good luck to Martin in his future plans and T? please don’t split up totally!!! What would I then listen?!?

But remember that there is always a change that this sad event turns in to positive one.. Like it happened when Grahan left - T? is more powerful with Neil than ever..

Keep on rockin’!!

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 10:44

#49

MarkoJii (Evil Twin) wrote:

Yeah Fabietto you hit to the nerve. The English gigs showed really cleary last year that Andy isn’t that great guitarist and when Martin was around he could consentrate more on vocals. Plus the live sound will be “thinner” without second guitar. And what about those cello-parts..? Are they going to use tapes or what?

Oh, boy I really hope that this wasn’t the wrong decision from Mihael & Andy…

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 10:49

#50

RatHype wrote:

No Martinair flying over future T? gigs? I’m gonna miss him, but I’m sure they ‘didn’t go on one night ice’. I was surprised about some of the replies I read and I have to admit, there are some very brave people on the boards! Good luck to Therapy? and Martin: het ga je goed!

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 11:11

#51

Beneath The underdog wrote:

Title: pointless speculation.

how can you people profess to *know* the reason for martin’s departure? this nonsense of “wanting to split the profits three ways, not four” is spurious, unfounded rubbish. theses guys are mates, I’m sure this decision wasn’t taken lightly.

martin is a talented musician who’s career goes much further back than his involvement with therapy?, he’ll be fine.

it’s my personal opinion that his best contribution to therapy? was made before he became a full time member. his guitar style was never right for the band.

it is also my opinion that therapy?’s golden period was 1990-95. i even enjoyed their live performances as a three piece much more.

the departure of hopkins was a start and hopefully this is the next step on the return to the glory days.

good luck martin, good luck therapy?

over and out.

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 11:28

#52

Beneath The underdog wrote:

good man, rat hype.

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 11:30

#53

Alan wrote:

Well, this is a discussion board and we’re having a discussion about what might have happened.

From a musical standpoint, there doesn’t seem to be a genuine reason for sacking Martin. Afterall, his songwriting contribution was more than Michaels, for instance. There’s also the fact his guitar and cello playing will be missed, not to mention his vocal ability.

From a personal point of view, I’ve never known the band members not to get along - they always seemed to be having great fun together. Even last week on this board, Martin was saying how much he was looking ofrward to getting back on tour with the lads.

Therefore, in my opinion only, it seems like it was a “business” decision to sack him. I could be wrong and I probably am wrong, it’s just that I want to read other peoples thoughts on the matter. Because as much as we say otherwise, and like to think otherwise, money is always an issue. And it could possibly be an issue here.

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 11:43

#54

JSar666 wrote:

Money seems to be the only logical explanation. Musically Martin added a lot, and they all seemed to get along well. Saying that splitting the profits 3 ways instead of 4 isn’t a factor is bullshit.

Do you think it’s easy for a band like T? to support themselves? In case you haven’t noticed, they’re not a Top 20 band anymore. Gigs, merch and royalties from previous albums are pretty much the only way for them to sustiain themselves, and if splitting the profits 3 ways is the only way for the band to be able to go on, then so be it. I’m sure the decision wasn’t taken lightly in any case.

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 11:49

#55

Auto_Surgery (Andy) wrote:

Wow, what a shock. Unless Martin makes a statement I doubt we’ll ever really know the real reason. Good luck Martin!

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 11:53

#56

Jobrok (John O)))) wrote:

There’s no doubt that T? will be a lesser band without Martin. And I don’t just mean in members.

He definitely made a huge contribution to the bands sound and style in his time with them.

But I’m going to hold judgement on the rest of the band members for a while. Until we all know for sure what went down.

Good luck, Martin!!!
Hope this is not the last we hear from you.

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 11:57

#57

PanZer wrote:

yep..! right…!

unless we get an explanation from the Therap’ guys (even through the webmasterz), we won’t know…

Martin was 1/4 of the band…and that funny cello sounded fucking good on T? music…

Martin, have a happy life, fun and all, and give some news from time to time…

*heavy sigh*

:(

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 12:00

#58

ColdEthyl? wrote:

Shit. And the day seemed not so bad till a few minutes ago. :( I missed Fyfe, I missed Graham, but Martin is something else. No idea if we’ll ever understand what happened but this is one of the saddest days for every Therapy?-fan. Blimey…

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 12:04

#59

ctrlaltdelete (chris) wrote:

Title: “I am the money????????”

Im alittle surprised that people think he was sacked, or left because of money so the others could have a bigger share…I could never see that being the reason, I could never see the other three ousting a friend over money matters…Maybe we should wait for one of them to saysomething…

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 12:07

#60

Nitro (Erdem Capar) wrote:

I think we have to stop this conversation, as T? is about to go on a tour and record a new album, these conversations about Martin may cause harm to the band.

It’s the best to say “Good luck” to both!

Posted on Fri, 19 March 2004 at 12:10

You’re viewing replies 31–60 of 269 by 109 people

·

Page: First | | | Last

and become a member of the message boards. Sign in if you’re already a member.