Welcome to the brand new Therapy? message boards! Find out what’s new or give us your feedback.

another bloody poll

#

Started by EvilElvis in General Therapy? Topics

i know you get fed up with polls, but i thought this one would be quite interesting

(Before changing the message boards’ software in August 2007 this discussion contained a poll, which may return in the future)

Posted on Mon, 5 April 2004 at 20:23

You’re viewing replies 1–30 of 31 by 22 people

·

Page: First | Previous | | Last

#1

hoochalobster (Sarah) Super Moderator wrote:

I went for the most recent line-up, whatever’s best for them is best for us :)

Posted on Mon, 5 April 2004 at 20:27

#2

Misanthropologist (d) wrote:

I feel sort of queasy. I voted for the recent line up as well, but now I feel I’ve betrayed Martin. And I miss Fyfe, too :( ANd now I feel guilty about leaving Graham out of the list of people I miss… Can I vote for them all? Bit pointless then, though, I suppose… :rolleyes:

Posted on Mon, 5 April 2004 at 21:05

#3

Bad Karma wrote:

I’m not going to vote until i hear some new material from the new line up.

Posted on Mon, 5 April 2004 at 21:08

#4

PanZer wrote:

i voted Andy, Michael, Martin & Graham as it was this lineup when my favorite abum was released…

Posted on Mon, 5 April 2004 at 21:13

#5

Andy D (Andy) wrote:

I voted for the line-up that actually wasn’t a permanent line-up (what is permanent?) so I voted for Andy, Michael, Fyfe adn Martin but actually I preferred the original line-up.

Posted on Mon, 5 April 2004 at 23:22

#6

allroy wrote:

This is one of the meanest polls of all times. it’s like asking a child whom it loves more: its mother or its father.

Posted on Tue, 6 April 2004 at 05:48

#7

MarkoJii (Ukko Perkele) wrote:

allroy is so right! This is the most evil poll ever in this board. We can discuss from this line-up thing forever.

Posted on Tue, 6 April 2004 at 06:19

#8

soul doubt (an) wrote:

I just can’t vote… I don’t want to. I always liked the line up although I preferred Fyfe as drummer mostly, he was the drummer when I got to know the band and I think therefore he’ll always have a step forward to Neil but Neil is an amazing drummer as well. And this all doensn’t mean I didn’t like Graham’s drumming.
I think it’s indeed a bit like allroy said.

Posted on Tue, 6 April 2004 at 06:44

#9

motherh666 wrote:

Wow. Evil. Looking at the results it’s fairly even so far.
Went for Fyfe, Martin. Sorry Neil. :rolleyes:

Posted on Tue, 6 April 2004 at 07:51

#10

Don't Call Me Honey wrote:

allroy wrote:

This is one of the meanest polls of all times. it’s like asking a child whom it loves more: its mother or its father.

‘zactly. I’m definitely not voting on this one unless I can vote for them all :rolleyes:

Posted on Tue, 6 April 2004 at 11:59

#11

mfgeorge wrote:

PanZer wrote:

i voted Andy, Michael, Martin & Graham as it was this lineup when my favorite abum was released…

agreed!

Posted on Tue, 6 April 2004 at 12:33

#12

RobbyVDH wrote:

I agree with allroy, this is an endless discussion and will probably lead again to people not agreeing on who the best drummer is :o

Posted on Tue, 6 April 2004 at 17:51

#13

deadsetgav wrote:

I’ve got to abstain - its too tough to call!

Posted on Tue, 6 April 2004 at 17:56

#14

motherh666 wrote:

The guy from Def Leppard? I mean the fuckers only got one arm!!!!!!!! :D

Posted on Tue, 6 April 2004 at 17:56

#15

RobbyVDH wrote:

:D

Posted on Tue, 6 April 2004 at 17:59

#16

Steve L wrote:

Does Fyfe still play in a band?

Posted on Tue, 6 April 2004 at 18:00

#17

ColdEthyl? wrote:

Oh dear, that’s cruel. That’s really, really cruel. I voted for Andy, Micheal, Martin and Fyfe, because, Fyfe was in when I became a fan, and Martin simply was… Martin. The guy who asked if I was ok when the stage diver knocked me out with his Doc Martens… (Not to mix with when Michael tried to knock me out with his bass guitar ;) ) Elephants never forget. :D

Posted on Wed, 7 April 2004 at 11:00

#18

needsometherapy wrote:

I voted for Andy, Michael, Martin & Neil …

I think Fyfe sounds better in the original trio but can’t see him being better than Neil in this line up …

As for Graham … he was ok .. but not the best drummer T? will ever have :eek:

Posted on Wed, 7 April 2004 at 15:48

#19

JSar666 wrote:

Therapy_G-13 wrote:

As for Graham … he was ok .. but not the best drummer T? will ever have :eek:

Stop right there! We don’t need another Fyfe vs. Graham vs. Neil thread on this board!

I’ve not voted yet, on the basis that I’ve not heard any of the creative output of the current line-up, but my hopes are high for the boys.

Posted on Wed, 7 April 2004 at 15:55

#20

motherh666 wrote:

Stop right there

Ehhmm. Ok.

Posted on Wed, 7 April 2004 at 16:04

#21

Reverend Savage? wrote:

JSar666 wrote:

Stop right there! We don’t need another Fyfe vs. Graham vs. Neil thread on this board!

Hmmmm. Well, I alway preferred them as a four piece so, for me in this poll, the only people to choose between are the drummers…

Sorry! :o

Posted on Wed, 7 April 2004 at 17:26

#22

innerdrive wrote:

I Voted just what i thought waht’s right even if its’dificult, but T? will always sounds great, because they find the musicians who are the best for T? strategy

Posted on Wed, 7 April 2004 at 19:35

#23

needsometherapy wrote:

Reverend Savage? wrote:

Hmmmm. Well, I alway preferred them as a four piece so, for me in this poll, the only people to choose between are the drummers…

Sorry! :o

Exactly …I was not trying to open a “drummer” conversation. Just comparing what the poll has to offer ;)

Posted on Wed, 7 April 2004 at 21:05

#24

not_that_kind_of_guy (a story on the radio) wrote:

i voted for the line up that created my favourite t? album (infernal love) although every line up has been great. but, i only first saw t? live on the suicide pact tour so perhaps i should’ve made a different choice. this poll should be divided into best studio line up and best live line up perhaps. oooh, this poll is mean. every line up is great. fuck it.

xxx

Posted on Wed, 7 April 2004 at 21:41

#25

motherh666 wrote:

Choice #6. Andy by himself with a banjo in Covent Garden singing ‘Stairway to heaven’. Wait. I made that up didn’t I?

Posted on Thu, 8 April 2004 at 09:12

#26

JSar666 wrote:

Ok, I’m sorry. I went a bit overboard. I just think the T? drummer debate has been done to death, even in the short time I’ve been here.

Posted on Thu, 8 April 2004 at 11:12

#27

ColdEthyl? wrote:

Reverend Savage? wrote:

Hmmmm. Well, I alway preferred them as a four piece so, for me in this poll, the only people to choose between are the drummers…

Sorry! :o

Agreed. That was my only intention as well. And I chose the line-up with Fyfe, as he was in the band “back then”. I liked Graham, and I probably like Neil. I don’t think T? ever had a bad drummer.

Posted on Thu, 8 April 2004 at 11:23

#28

3ddo-on-the-balcony (eddo) wrote:

You said it! T? never had a bad drummer. That’s also why I cannot and don’t want to make a choice. All line-ups are unique and therefore not comparable.

There’s one missing though: Andy and Martin. I saw them play a semi-acoustic set in an old church in Den Haag. Andy smashed a Gibson Les Paul and gave it to a bloke in the audience.
It almost was Andy, Martin & 3ddo in one song, but due to miscommunication and a misunderstanding from my side (fucking language) it was abandoned even before it started :rolleyes:

Posted on Thu, 8 April 2004 at 14:35

#29

JSar666 wrote:

D’oh! I’d give my left testicle to play with T? Live and learn 3ddo

Posted on Thu, 8 April 2004 at 16:34

#30

3ddo-on-the-balcony (eddo) wrote:

Yeah, yeah, I’d give my right (or my middle one) It was a good lesson, tought afterwards by the great Mr McC. But I know i’ll get a second chance.. someday :D

Posted on Thu, 8 April 2004 at 19:55

You’re viewing replies 1–30 of 31 by 22 people

·

Page: First | Previous | | Last

and become a member of the message boards. Sign in if you’re already a member.