Welcome to the brand new Therapy? message boards! Find out what’s new or give us your feedback.

A few questions about the guitar…

#

Started by matthew

Here goes…

1. Is it easier to play the electric compared to a classical guitar. I’d have to say that it depends because I think the strings on a classical are further apart and therefore the player has less chance of accidentally muting other strings. Yet electrics strings aren’t that high off the neck therefore barre chords are easier.

2. Why do classical guitars have so few frets? Is it because classical guitarists don’t really play parts that are really high pitch, well obviously they don’t do full on metal solos but why the limitation?

3. Why the hell do bassists only play one string at a time, I swear I’ve got thousands of tabs and all bassists ever do is play on one string at a time. Why not break a leg and play three or four at a time just like a rock guitarist?? Will it sound muddy or something, I don’t get it think of all the possibilities of playing different amounts of stings and gettings variations in sound.

4. How many types of barre chords are there? I know of the A based barre chord and the E based barre chord but are there others.

5. I see on many band message boards that people rip off Kirk Hammet a lot because he uses pentatonic scales a lot. I don’t know jack shit about scales but is the pentatonic scale for pussies or something?

Posted on Tue, 27 December 2005 at 18:16

You’re viewing replies 1–20 of 20 by 8 people

·

Page: First | Previous | Next | Last

#1

buffalo-boy wrote:

I’m sure there will be disagreements here but here goes:

1)Yes, electric guitars have thinner necks and the strings are closer together making them easier to play. Plus they have metal strings as opposed to nylon ones which makes them ring out more.

2) The less frets you have the more creative you have to be. Compare a John Williams score with a rock guitar one and you’ll see where you need the most technique and skill. Please no-one start an argument going ‘its not about technique, its about feeling…blah blah’ I know this, its an example, ok?!

3)Because holding a bass string down is like playing a steel girder in comparison to nancy guitar strings. And note that most bands these days have started emulating the bass on guitar by playing low tuned, one string riffs and concentrating on rhythm ala bass. See Evanescence, T?, QOTSA, Metallica. Bass is about rhythm AND notes.

4) Major and minor are the main ones but you could change fingering slightly to do the 7ths aswell so 2 really.

5) There’s no such thing as a scale for pussies, its all beautiful music! Note choice is down to the individual, so make them good ones!

Posted on Wed, 28 December 2005 at 11:57

#2

viking_pooh wrote:

3) go look at bass tabs for “Sober” by Tool and “Please Sir” by Pitchshifter, or better still find live videos and watch the bass player, as both those songs feature awesome use of chords on bass which form the main rhythm part and are often mistaken for guitar, and while some low end bass chords sound muddy and crap, higher up the neck they sound awesomely fat, espeiclaly wiht distortion. and theres many many many more tunes and bass player that use bass chords, try some jazz on for size.

Posted on Fri, 30 December 2005 at 20:30

#3

matthew wrote:

Hi guys, I just got my reply from Michael, here it is.

Aha…the million dollar question! To be honest Matthew I’m a self taught
bassist so I don’t know any theory or stuff like that. I just play what
sounds cool and what works with the songs our band plays.

To be honest most ‘rock’ bassist are there to enhance and complement what
the guitarist and drummer are doing. The weird thing is that the bass has
to deal with melody and rythmn all the time…there’s no point locking
into the drums if the notes are all wrong with the chords and there’s no
poit playing a nice counter melody if the timing clashes with the drum
pattern. As a result I just try and find something in the middle so the
song grooves along.

As regards the two(or more) string thing…I’m not sure if you’ve ever
played a bass guitar before…but normally chords on a bass (apart from
5ths etc) sound really nasty. If you’ve got a very nice clean sound, sure
you can pick out a few tasty chords, but once the volume increases all
sort s of overtones appear and it can sound badly out of tune. That’s why
i feel a lot of bassist stick to single notes so not to ‘cloud’ what the
guitarist is doing especially if they’re both playing in the same tonal
range. Of course when the guitar is playing higher stuff it’s easier to
slip chords in but then again,personally I prefer to do them higher up the
neck to avoid the dreaded overtones.

That’s just from a rock/heavy rock/punk perspective…jazz(Charlie
Mingus) and fusion (Jaco P) all have many different ways of phrasing
chords and multiple string parts. If you want to hear nice bass chords I’d
suggest Flea from the Chilli Peppers on some of their slower
songs…though he’s in a postion where their guitarist uses very little
distortion and has a lot of space to work in.

And another thing…those bass strings are big thick fuckers so if you
ain’t got a strong wrist you ain’t gonna move them, chords or no chords.

If you get a chance check out my fave bass players, all for different
reasons…Cliff Williams (AC/DC)-simple, solid, all down strokes. Geezer
Butler(Black Sabbath)-jazzy,funky and plays in and around the riff/beat.
Cliff Burton(early Metallica)-chords, runs, solos, harmonies, a very
innovative guy.

Hope that’s of some use to you.

Michaelx

Buffalo-boy I don’t understand what is rhythmic about a bass, surely a guitarist can provide more rhythm than a bass player. He can pick faster anyway. I suppose the bass player usually locks in with the kick drum though, so is that rhythm for ya?
Thanks!

Posted on Sun, 1 January 2006 at 14:21

#4

Moint wrote:

Hoi Matthew,

ad 1.)

That depends. After a pause lasting for a few years, i started to play guitar again on a western guitar (an Ibanez AEL20 to be exactly). In comparison to a classical guitar, the western guitar uses a tighter neck (like the electrical ones) and metal strings. I was suprised about how easy it was to play barre chords on this guitar (i had an experience of about four years of playing guitars before), but i was also suprised about the blood blisters at my finger tips. Overall: Just practise, practise, practise, practise, practise, regardless which guitar you like to play. It took me one year of practising every day to play barre chords easily on my guitars. Remember to practise the switching between chords often!!

ad 2.)

I don’t know. My western guitar has some more frets, than my classical guitar has, but anyway too less frets to play my version of silent night :D

ad 3.)

Just have a look at Bootsy Collins or Lenny Kilmister. They play their basses as were they just guitars with heavier gauge strings. As far as i know Bootsy Collins turned some guitars in basses just by putting bass strings on his guitar.

ad 4.)

Get yourself a copy of “in vivo guitar” from Abi von Reininghaus. I don’t know if this book is also available in english, but it helped me a lot in understanding music theory used with guitars.
Simplified spoken you can play every chord barre. Major/Minor/dim5/add9/etc..

ad 5.)

Pentatonic scales are scales which lack the existence of halftones.
“Normal” scales have seven (or eight tones if you take the octave into account) tones, five “normal” tones and two halftones. The placement of the halftones within the scale determine the scale itself. Major scales have the halfton steps between the 3rd/4th and 7th/8th step, whereas minor scales have the halfton steps between 2nd/3rd and 5th/6th step. Pentatonic scales just have those five “normal” tones, which some might think makes them easy to play (IMHO those guys are the real pussies :)).

If you are really interested in music theory get a copy of the book mentioned above. Be aware that this books intention is not to teach you how to play guitar, but it will help you in understanding the theory behind chords/scales/etc.

Best wishes,

Posted on Mon, 2 January 2006 at 15:33

#5

buffalo-boy wrote:

Buffalo-boy I don’t understand what is rhythmic about a bass, surely a guitarist can provide more rhythm than a bass player. He can pick faster anyway. I suppose the bass player usually locks in with the kick drum though, so is that rhythm for ya?
Thanks!

Hmmm, i don’t think there’s a right answer here, i guess it depends who plays the most rhythmically! Personally in my band we hear the song and us rhythm section dudes create the rhythm to propel the guitar and vocals but i’m sure there are plenty of bands where the drummer makes something out of what the guitarist is doing and sometimes riffs come out of a drumbeat too!
Michael is right of course though, us bassists have to stick to the rhythm and notes ALL the time (unless soloing. Guitar is a bit more fun in this area, but then again holding the song together is fun too. Thats why i use lots of distortion and chords so people know its me and go “Fuck me! What was that!” haha, try it!
As for being able to pick faster on guitar generally yes, but i can do thrash metal with my fingers Rob Truhillo style, most bassists are just lazy - its not hard so i guess im the exception to your rule!

Posted on Tue, 3 January 2006 at 08:39

#6

Misanthropologist (d) wrote:

To what buffalo-boy said, I’d add that playing fast and playing rhythmically aren’t necessarily the same thing. ;)

Posted on Tue, 3 January 2006 at 11:44

#7

buffalo-boy wrote:

Musical questions are always hard to answer cos there’s infinite ways of doing things and not necessarily a right way, though when it comes to chords there are simpler ways around things.

Posted on Tue, 3 January 2006 at 15:42

#8

matthew wrote:

Thanks for all your help guys, really appreciate it.
I find I’m better at messing around with individual strings than playing whole chords. I wish I could download more traditional folk music, because I want to learn tunes that are played solo if you know what I mean. I mean there are so many tabs of bands riffs but sometimes the riffs need to played with the bass line and the singer’s vocal’s to sound any good.
They can sound pretty insignificant on their own.
I’ve tried playing somebas tabs with a pick and with fingers and all I gotta say is that if bass is’nt that much easier than playing the top four strings of a classical guitar, then bass is way easy. Hooray for bass!
Hooray for playting single strings!
Moint I’ll have to check out that book, better be in English though, hehe.

Posted on Fri, 6 January 2006 at 21:18

#9

buffalo-boy wrote:

I’ve found that on guitar you can translate any riff into a chord sequence and play it strummed rather than single notes. Try and do it yourself. For example Die Laughing is a note based riff but you can play the chords (G and E for the verse) and when you sing over it it will sound better than just playing the single notes which sound wimpy on their own!

Posted on Tue, 10 January 2006 at 08:53

#10

Idlevice2 wrote:

Bass chords… check out Les Claypool’s flamenco power chord sennanigans eg. Too Many Puppies by Primus.

Posted on Tue, 17 January 2006 at 21:41

#11

Idlevice2 wrote:

buffalo-boy wrote:

I’ve found that on guitar you can translate any riff into a chord sequence and play it strummed rather than single notes. Try and do it yourself. For example Die Laughing is a note based riff but you can play the chords (G and E for the verse) and when you sing over it it will sound better than just playing the single notes which sound wimpy on their own!

They’re called root notes.

Posted on Tue, 17 January 2006 at 21:42

#12

deekoi wrote:

buffalo-boy wrote:

Buffalo-boy I don’t understand what is rhythmic about a bass, surely a guitarist can provide more rhythm than a bass player. He can pick faster anyway. I suppose the bass player usually locks in with the kick drum though, so is that rhythm for ya?
Thanks!

Buffalo boy; the bass plays plays ina lower register sonically to the guitar. even playing a note which is also on a guitar, due to the thickness of the strings, the way bass amps work and the electrics of the bass itself, the note will have more ‘low-end’ tonally than the guitar, for which the sound is produced with more mid-range. play with the treble and bass knobs on your guitar or amp to see what i mean.

This means that when a bass player ‘locks in’ with a beat played on the kick drum, it makes both sound more powerful. Through a venue PA system this sounds incredible. have a listen to any rock music and try to imagine it without the kick drum or the low end of the bass and you’ll see why it’s also a rythem instrument.

In terms of playing only one note, that single note, being lower than the guitar, can change so much of the music itself. Playing the same root note as the guitarist’s chord will cause the tune to sound tighter, and punky; however if you then play a note three frets lower, you’ll change the overall sound of what the guitar player is doing, and end up with a more ‘progressive’ sound. get a guitar playing friend and try this:

Whilst he plays the following progression: A minor / D minor / C major / G major; you play A, D, C and G. then keep him playing this, whilst you play C, F, A, E.

what the two of your are playing as a whole is Amin, Dmin, C and G in the first instance. in the second, where you are playing different notes, the resultant chords will be C, F, Amin, Emin. you’ve changed what he’s playing but just playing single notes. It’s awesome!

if you need tab or anything let me know.

PS in terms of the differences between electric and spanish (nylon strung) guitars, one of the biggest is that they are played differently. Electrics can be beaten and battered, changed through effects, and amplified loudly. Spanish guitars are virtually almost played fingerstyle (so strings are further apart in order to get your right hand fingers between them), and are normally amplified through the use of careful microphone placement. i can’t thing of a single classical guitarist who would use effects either. It’s not just the way in which they’re played, but the objectives of the people playing them too remember!

Posted on Tue, 17 January 2006 at 21:54

#13

Idlevice2 wrote:

Ah yes, good old relative major/minors. A relative minor is 3 semi-tones down from it’s relative major (like C maj and A min), so you need to work out what key you’re in then move 3 frets up or down depending.

Posted on Wed, 18 January 2006 at 14:46

#14

buffalo-boy wrote:

er…deekoi, why are you telling me those things above - i have an HND in music!!! I was putting things in simple terms for those of us who are beginners or who can’t be arsed to learn theory!

Posted on Tue, 24 January 2006 at 13:15

#15

deekoi wrote:

actually buffalo boy, i was quoting you quoting michael, i’m sorry, that was probably unclear. I did not know that you have a HND in music, what area? (i.e music tech / music performance .etc.. i list these two becuase that’s all that was on offer when i did it, i’m not suggesting it’s necessarily either of those)

Other than the first paragraph (the quote) i was writing form a beginner’s perspective as well.

I also would have thought that if there was a theory element to our music course, you might have also known about root notes (see Idledevice’s reply to your previous post), especially if you’re playing thrash metal; which is essentially root notes and pedal baased riffs.

Posted on Wed, 25 January 2006 at 21:56

#16

buffalo-boy wrote:

Aha! Sorry dude! I didn’t get that,my fault!

The course was contemporary music in bass guitar and yes, there was LOTS of theory. I am not really a thrash metaller - i ws just saying that I can play those speeds with my fingers - its not impossible! I play in a good old fashioned rock n roll band! My favourite type of basslines are the ones that follow the vocal melody but still play really rhythmically ( and i’m damned if i can think of a single example of a good un now!) but yeah, know what u mean about root notes. Check out the yo-yo’s - he plays really simply but sounds great. I keep thinking how much i want him to stick a tasty fill in those gaps! (No double entendre’s please!!!)

Posted on Thu, 26 January 2006 at 09:27

#17

Idlevice2 wrote:

I can play ay faster with a pick than my fingers on bass (duh) but I can still do thrash with my fingers… oh, and did I mention Les Claypool earlier? I saw a video of him playing master of puppets with his thumb- slapping every note (including the guitar intro part). Try it- it be not easy.

Posted on Thu, 16 February 2006 at 19:31

#18

deadsetgav wrote:

I’m sure Les Claypools main role in life is to remind every aspiring musician, that no matter how good you may think you might be, you dont know shit when it comes to playing bass!

Posted on Fri, 17 February 2006 at 07:12

#19

buffalo-boy wrote:

I have to be honest dudes - what i’ve heard of Primus I absolutely HATE!!!! But i would like to study Les, can you recommend a cool place to start?

Posted on Thu, 23 February 2006 at 08:33

#20

Idlevice2 wrote:

buffalo-boy wrote:

I have to be honest dudes - what i’ve heard of Primus I absolutely HATE!!!! But i would like to study Les, can you recommend a cool place to start?

His new DVD (5 Gallon Diesel) or the ‘Animals Should Not Try To Act Like People’ DVD

Posted on Thu, 23 February 2006 at 15:31

There are no more replies in this discussion. (Go to the homepage)

to post a reply. Sign in if you’re already a member.

You’re viewing replies 1–20 of 20 by 8 people

·

Page: First | Previous | Next | Last

Other discussions started by matthew

Title Replies Started Last post
just listening to testament 5
I want to buy a gun. 86
Devin Townsend 58
We’re ill, we wipe our arses… 13
Alan Partridge 30

View all 45 discussions started by matthew.