Wall of Mouths

Potato Junkie 75
Accelerator 50
Tightrope Walker 70
Gone 40
Femtex 75
Loose 35
Perish the Thought 25 +
Trigger Inside 70
Nausea 70
Jam Jar Jail 60 -

Dermot wrote:

Chr1s!! What are you doin to me man!? ;-)

:D It’s a tough vote… I LIKE Perish The Thought and Jam Jar Jail will survive :)

Thefanthattriedtostrangleitslf wrote:

Jam Jar Jail is one of the most brilliant ROCK songs Therapy? ever wrote and would have been a classic if it had been released as a single, hands off :p

Jam Jar Jail migth have been a big hit as well, if it had the name “Queens of the Stone Age” put on it.

Potato Junkie 75
Accelerator 45
Tightrope Walker 70
Gone 40
Femtex 75
Loose 20 -
Perish the Thought 25
Trigger Inside 75
Nausea 75 +
Jam Jar Jail 70

Potato Junkie 75
Accelerator 45
Tightrope Walker 70 -
Gone 40
Femtex 75
Loose 25 +
Perish the Thought 20
Trigger Inside 75
Nausea 75
Jam Jar Jail 70

Tightrope Walker should be 75 +

hoochalobster wrote:

@An If people are in agreement about the rule change, I can edit your original post to include this rule?

Who agrees/disagrees with changing the rules, so that the one who’s putting a song into the hall of fame/shame is not choosing a new song, but the next person to vote is to choose the replacement song? This way, no more songs will end up into the hall of shame just for the sake of being able to choose a new track (as some people suspect is happening at the moment).

There’s one thing though, if we change the rules, you cannot expect people who are already joining in and are not reading every post in this topic will know about the change. It’s very unlikely they read the rules, every time they join in. :)

Jobrok wrote:

I say, ‘YES’. Edit the original post.

And add the rule that you can’t simultaniously put two songs into the HOF and HOS at the same time.

I don’t want to mess with the rules too much, and I don’t think it happened a lot that someone gets the chance to put a song into the HOF and HOS at the same time, so I’d keep it this way, unless a lot of people disagree with me on this ;)

chr1s wrote:

:D It’s a tough vote… I LIKE Perish The Thought and Jam Jar Jail will survive :)

yeah, it´s really tough to give the plus and minus votes here..Jam Jar Jail is an excellent song as are Deluded Son, Polar Bear, Tango Romeo etc. etc. who are in that Hall of “shame” now..I dont understand you who voted those songs there, as I dont understand myself giving minus to JJJ but…maby this voting ends for me now as I cannot decide and every song should be in the hall of fame imo

Potato Junkie 75
Accelerator 40 -
Tightrope Walker 75
Gone 35
Femtex 80
Loose 15
Perish the Thought 30 +
Trigger Inside 75
Nausea 75
Jam Jar Jail 70

Truer words were never spoken. I agree on having the next person decide the new song though.

I have edited the rules originally posted by An. From now on, if you place a song in the Hall of Fame or Shame, the NEXT POSTER chooses the replacement song.

^Hopefully with the bold it’ll stand out and people will notice :)

I really want Tightrope Walker in there but I’ll help out Loose tomorrow, because it’s pretty great.

Potato Junkie 75
Accelerator 35
Tightrope Walker 75 +
Gone 35
Femtex 80
Loose 15
Perish the Thought 30
Trigger Inside 80
Nausea 70 -
Jam Jar Jail 75

Potato Junkie 75
Accelerator 35
Tightrope Walker 75
Gone 35
Femtex 80
Loose 15
Perish the Thought 25-
Trigger Inside 80
Nausea 70
Jam Jar Jail 80+

Potato Junkie 75
Accelerator 35
Tightrope Walker 70-
Gone 30
Femtex 80
Loose 20+
Perish the Thought 30
Trigger Inside 80
Nausea 70
Jam Jar Jail 80