Buy our new album “A Brief Crack Of Light” on CD or limited edition vinyl at Amazon.co.uk, or direct from Global Music

Andy’s singing qualities

#

Started by Thefanthattriedtostrangleitslf in General Therapy? Topics

So how would we rate Andy as a singer?

Posted on Mon, 23 August 2010 at 10:27

You’re viewing replies 1–25 of 25 by 21 people

·

Page: First | Previous | Next | Last

#1

caffeinebomb (Caffeine Bomb) wrote:

he’s alrite.

Posted on Mon, 23 August 2010 at 10:34

#2

buffalo-boy wrote:

Not the most in tune singer of all time but a great rock voice!

Posted on Mon, 23 August 2010 at 10:47

#3

Alan wrote:

Better back in the 90’s, especially live. His live vocals since the 2000’s hasn’t been great though, a lot of vocal parts are being growled now instead of singing.

Posted on Mon, 23 August 2010 at 10:56

#4

soul doubt (an) wrote:

He’s got his moments, sometimes he’s just saying some of his vocal parts even, instead of growling or singing :D
He was indeed a lot better in the 90’s, but I think that’s normal after such intens touring for such a long time.

Posted on Mon, 23 August 2010 at 11:18

#5

Pip (Philip Kelly) wrote:

He has a very destinctive

Posted on Mon, 23 August 2010 at 13:33

#6

Pip (Philip Kelly) wrote:

Vocal ^

Posted on Mon, 23 August 2010 at 13:33

#7

MOSH666 wrote:

I agree with everyone - I think Andy knows his vocal limitations, but T? wouldn’t be T? without Andy’s distinctive vocals.

Posted on Mon, 23 August 2010 at 13:39

#8

realityfuck (Richard Splash) wrote:

I think he’s a damn fine singer. He’ll never be Freddie Mercury or Jeff Buckley (or Mike Patton or Greg Dulli…) but he’s very expressive and really sings from the bottom of his heart.

Posted on Mon, 23 August 2010 at 16:55

#9

chr1s (I can't remember my own name) wrote:

I really couldn’t imagine anyone else singing T? songs any better… I think Andy’s voice is perfect for the sound of the band as a whole. And live, he makes the older songs from when his voice was fresher, sound somehow better…

Dunno if i’m coming across properly, but at least I know what i mean :D

Posted on Mon, 23 August 2010 at 17:21

#10

kossu (Petri Koskiniemi) wrote:

I luv Andys vocals (well that´s no surprise;)) They were the 1st thing that got me interested in T?. For me it´s the same what he´s singing, fast or slow, pure quality for my ears. He´s not a Freddy Mercury (thank god/or devil;)), he´s Andy! And ofcourse he cannot sing like “a young boy” at this point when he´s over 40…but I´m sure we can all live with that, right:D

Posted on Mon, 23 August 2010 at 17:32

#11

trigger wrote:

yeah andy has a distinctive voice, i really liked the way he sung in the early nineties in nurse, the ‘93 ep’s and troublegum. especially songs like turn, neck freak, opal mantra, unbeliever. in infernal love and semi detached it was ok but not as great ( with the exception of epilepsy for me). hearing suicide pact was kind of a shock of course, this record has some really demented vocals. i think his studio performance in the records from high anxiety onwards has deteriorated (maybe due to lack of appropriate studio time?), but in crooked timber he did get better so that gives me some hope he’ll sound even better on the next album… i don’t know, maybe he doesn’t consider that important to write good vocal melodies anymore so he doesn’t put that much effort into it?
live he was never too great to begin with… he’s decent and he’s trying though ;)

Posted on Mon, 23 August 2010 at 19:46

#12

glen wrote:

he keeps his accent, which alot of singers dont

Posted on Mon, 23 August 2010 at 19:57

#13

RoyBatty (Steve) wrote:

I liken Andy’s vox to a harder edged Peter Gabriel: while not technically trained, he is uses what he has in unusual and interesting ways. Not afraid of taking chances, he can sound vastly different depending on what he feels the song needs. I think he sounds great on CT, age not seeming to matter so much as he’s not a screamer like Lemmy or Hetfield.

I can’t opine whether he sucks live though, because Americans seem to be afraid of good music at the moment. :-D

Posted on Mon, 23 August 2010 at 20:04

#14

Cactus wrote:

So, what production suited his voice best so far?

I have to say I love the production on the minialbums where he kind of sounds like he’s bellowing from the next room, but then I’m a sucker for BT/PD.

He sounds good and unhinged on Suicide Pact, and that growly thing he unleashed on that album was pretty startling at the time - love it. He’s good at the guttural gurgling thing.

I think on Nurse it’s like they did the ‘using vocals as another instrument thing’ to great effect on stuff like Gone and, say, the chorus of Perversonality. I guess he’s a singer who isn’t afraid to try different approaches, sometimes he’s a crooner, sometimes he has that slightly American rock twang, I loved the pronounced Irish accent on Crooked Timber though.

Also, not sure if anyone would agree here - possibly my favourite singer at saying ‘YEAH’ in a wide variety of cool ways - start of Gimme Back my Brain, chorus in Stories, even the ‘Yeah’ in Fear of God is a beauty. Oh, and good ones in Joey too. Anyone else think of other good Cairns ‘yeah’ moments? I’m pretty sure there’s a great one on NANE, just not coming back to me right now.

God I always do this, don’t post for months then prattle on for pages and pages…

Posted on Mon, 23 August 2010 at 23:08

#15

interzone (Order and method) wrote:

I think Andy was at his top while Infernal Love. Now sometimes and especially when he sings some powerful verses or chorus, his voice looks like James Hetfield’s one. But his voice keeps cool to hear it anyway.

Posted on Tue, 24 August 2010 at 00:29

#16

interzone (Order and method) wrote:

Hope he’s not breathless !

Posted on Tue, 24 August 2010 at 00:33

#17

fatboy wrote:

He’s not Michael Bolton or those serious 80’s singers (thankfully) but his vocals are good for the job, end of.

Posted on Tue, 24 August 2010 at 07:06

#18

Bad Astronaut (Your mommy's alright, your daddy's alright....) wrote:

He always feels the feel. A Moment of Clarity to Danzig esque He’s Not That Kind of Girl. He tried different things too; like Straight Life, God Kicks or Dance. I thing his highlight is A Boy’s Asleep but he’s real aim is whole Never Apologise Never Explain record – This is Andy’s most comfortable soul, like a reflection. My favorite is Infernal Love though. Great pain, greater shame and anger. Anti – White Noise.

Posted on Tue, 24 August 2010 at 12:11

#19

KJC Dublin (Karl) wrote:

I couldn’t imagine a different voice for this band. I liked particularly in the old days when he used to shout and scream like a drunken maniac (check out Shit Kicker)…

One thing you have to give him as well is the fact that he can sing across a multitude of musical backdrops (not many T? track albums that are the same).

Kind of digging the whole mature trip at the moment as well (I think CT is the first album where there is no “Fuck”) - still effective, albeit in a different way.

Posted on Tue, 24 August 2010 at 12:19

#20

Christian wrote:

Cactus wrote:

So, what production suited his voice best so far?

I have to say I love the production on the minialbums where he kind of sounds like he’s bellowing from the next room, but then I’m a sucker for BT/PD.

He sounds good and unhinged on Suicide Pact, and that growly thing he unleashed on that album was pretty startling at the time - love it. He’s good at the guttural gurgling thing.

Funnily enough, Andy once said regarding BT/PD “we put so much distortion on it, because none of us could sing”.
Heh, I bet never he could imagine back then we he did those albums, he’d later do something like Diane.

Personally, I’m of the opinion that Andy doesn’t sound quite as good as he used to be on the last two albums. Live there was always a lot of variety in performance levels, I believe. One comment over at youtube cracked me up, it was also about a Diane performance (I think paradiso), where someone remarked that this must be an imposter, because the singing was so wrong. Of course, Andy is perfectly able to sing the song in a very nice way (I’d say the acoustic performance from Den Haag with Martin is superior to the one on the record for example, but then I have to say that I’m not overly fond of the Infernal Love version in the first place, I prefer the re-recorded one).

Also, I agree that Andy has a talent for the guttural gurgling thing without sounding cartoonish, it sounds good in a crazy way. But then, Suicide Pact also features Six-Mile Water, and I don’t think that’s out of place either.

Posted on Tue, 24 August 2010 at 12:31 in reply to an earlier post

#21

buffalo-boy wrote:

It takes bollocks to sing a song like ‘Diane’ - especially when youre not known for being a ‘proper’ singer. In fact, I’d love to ask him where he got the confidence and voice to do that. And Bowels Of Love - great vocal.

I didn’t like that unhinged stuff on SPYF, thought it was a big step backwards leaving it all one take and out of tune. Brave, certainly tho!

Posted on Tue, 24 August 2010 at 17:42

#22

Alex wrote:

I absolutely love the “unhinged stuff” on SPYF. Really hope a few more songs in the future will take this direction…

Posted on Tue, 24 August 2010 at 21:18

#23

TheSingularity101 (Dr. Rick Dagless, M.D) wrote:

At least he isn’t Billy Corgan.

Posted on Thu, 26 August 2010 at 20:43

#24

RoyBatty (Steve) wrote:

I reckon he’s a better singer than most on this board! :-)

Posted on Fri, 27 August 2010 at 18:21

#25

dubbass (Just another company man) wrote:

i guess he’s allright. the biggest problem is that he has to play the guitar also simultaneously during the shows. I know well that feeling, since i’m also playing the bass guitar and signing at a local band, so it sucks. This can be proved, when Martin was at the band, so his singing was great.

The voice is perfect for such this band and this is one of the advantages. Meaning that his voice is so characteristic(and that’s a Greek word) that if you heard it once, you will never forget it.
If i had to say a disadvantage, that would be that he seems to be out of tune most of the time during the shows. Last show in Greece, if anyone has heard it on dimedozen, it was totaly out of tune all the time :). But there is an explanation, i think that he drunk too much ouzo that night lol.

And of course he’s a great singer than anyone on this board RoyBatty.

Posted on Tue, 31 August 2010 at 10:36

There are no more replies in this discussion. (Go to the homepage)

to post a reply. Sign in if you’re already a member.

You’re viewing replies 1–25 of 25 by 21 people

·

Page: First | Previous | Next | Last

Other discussions started by Thefanthattriedtostrangleitslf

Title Replies Started Last post
Fan made stuff in General Therapy? Topics 12 Yesterday, 20:52
by Thefanthattriedtostrangleitslf		 Today, 00:33
by Squall
Funny lyrics in General Therapy? Topics 5 7 Feb 2012
by Thefanthattriedtostrangleitslf		 11 Feb 2012
by buffalo-boy
Songs that sound like Therapy? in General Therapy? Topics 20 22 Jan 2012
by Thefanthattriedtostrangleitslf		 9 Feb 2012
by caffeinebomb
Memorable Andy Quotes in General Therapy? Topics 29 16 May 2011
by Thefanthattriedtostrangleitslf		 20 Jan 2012
by Fiona
Support? in Therapy? Live 7 28 Dec 2011
by Thefanthattriedtostrangleitslf		 5 Jan 2012
by MisterHoppy

View all 39 discussions started by Thefanthattriedtostrangleitslf.