Welcome to the brand new Therapy? message boards! Find out what’s new or give us your feedback.

My opinion…

#

Started by Charlie in General Therapy? Topics

In My opinion, the Ark 21 years were the worst therapy albums.

Nurse
Troublegum
Infernal Love
Semi Detached

( all great albums )

Suicide Pact
Shameless
Ten year Plan

( hmmmmmmmm… )

High Anxiety

( We’re Back :D )

I know a lot of you like SP:YF but I cant really get into it…And shameless is only half a good album…

I’m really looking forward to the next one :cool:

Posted on Mon, 9 June 2003 at 10:03

You’re viewing replies 1–19 of 19 by 12 people

·

Page: First | Previous | Next | Last

#1

mooneycult wrote:

i still fail to see the massive differences between shameless and HA. ok HA is more consistent and a bit more in-your-face but there isn’t really a huge progession from shameless.

unlike some people am a fan of both shameless and HA but i think t? need to throw another one of their trademark curveballs for the next album - 3 albums of straightforward punked up rock n’ roll in a row would just be tedious.

Posted on Mon, 9 June 2003 at 10:19

#2

Hecubus wrote:

i tend to agree with mooney, Shameless and HA are pretty similar — although i do think HA is better front-to-back. with more listens, i found myself getting bored with about half of Shameless. who knows, HA is still pretty fresh to me, the same thing might happen with it. i’d also like to see another “curveball” with the next album. one of T?’s greatest strengths, to me, has been their ability to change up their sound while always making great music. another album in the Shameless/HA vein and i’d be close to advocating retirement…

Suicide Pact took me a loooooooong time to really appreciate. couldn’t stand it at first, but i persevered and over time each song grew on me. there’s a lot more going on there than appears at first, and it’s all pretty excellent.

edit — i’m an idiot.

Posted on Mon, 9 June 2003 at 15:21

#3

Cringe wrote:

If yer ask me (and no-one did, since I’m new and isolated from the group dynamic ;)), SP-YF is one of Therapy?’s finest hours. It’s a corker of an album.

When it comes to Shameless and High Anxiety…
Well, I have to agree with the folks in this thread. HA seems to be just more of the same kind of stuf from the Shameless album. I like both albums a lot… but, and I may be alone on this, I actually think Shameless is a better LP all round, when compared to HA.

I think people are still on the high from having a new T? LP to bang their heads to. Once they’ve calmed down and really listen to it, and see how it sqaures up to the band’s illustrious discography, they’ll see that it’s very good yes, but not as good as the last few records.

Don’t get me wrong… I love High Anxiety… I just don’t rate it above anything from the Ark21 years. For all those who don’t rate Shameless, I advise several more listens. It’s a great wee record, in my humble opinion.

Posted on Mon, 9 June 2003 at 16:30

#4

Hecubus wrote:

this is where i’m torn on the Shameless/HA thing. i think there was a greater disparity between the good songs and the clunkers on Shameless, while HA is more consistent throughout: none of the good tracks reach the same heights as the good ones from Shameless, but the low points aren’t as low, either.

the songs on Shameless that are good are very, very good. but the bad ones are almost unlistenable…

Posted on Mon, 9 June 2003 at 16:49

#5

prisonbreaker wrote:

shameless and sp-yf are fine records, only S-D isn’t that good, I think

Posted on Mon, 9 June 2003 at 20:03

#6

hoochalobster (Sarah) Super Moderator wrote:

Title: My two cents…

I think tomorrow I will spend the day listening to Shameless and then talk more. I have it in my head that it’s crap (I use crap in the comparative sense to other T? albums) but I think that it was more the disappointment that it wasn’t how I wanted that put me off it.

This is a guess, after tomorrow I may come back and say no, I was right, it’s bollocks. But we’ll see. It’s the only album I’ve ever been disappointed with and not instantly liked though.

Posted on Mon, 9 June 2003 at 22:24

#7

Cringe wrote:

Semi-Detached is the only record that’s really disappointed me from Therapy?
I got very nearly expelled from school for mitching off on the day it was released, to go and buy a copy in Belfast then go home and spend the day listening to it. I hated it for a long time, but over the last five or so years, it’s definitely grown on me.

I remember hearing Church of Noise for the first time, and being convinced it was some kind of terrible joke… then the album came out, and it in itself was even worse on the whole.

I met Michael McKeegan at an Ash gig in Belfast the year of Semi-Detached… I talked to him for a bit, and said as nicely as I could that I didn’t think much of Semi-Detached, and he himself sort of gave me a funny knowing look and said “Yeah, I know… not our best”, or something along those lines. That was only a few months after it came out.

But like I say, once it’s had time to work it’s way into your head, it’s a pretty good LP.

Posted on Tue, 10 June 2003 at 18:08

#8

utookmenaiveandugly wrote:

I think Shameless has brilliant songs on it, but it might be the case rather than listening in one whole go, maybe a few tracks at a time, songs like Joey and Wicked Man are up there but the album does tail off a bit towards the end. Same with Semi Detached, tightrope walker, don’t expect roses, lonly cryin.. and the boys asleep are great but over the course of the album they don’t sound they’re best.Suicide Pact is immense, a real two fingers to all record execs, and i admit it took ages for it all to sink in, though i’m glad it did.
High Anxiety is brilliant I think, the hooks are there, my favourite changes daily which can only be a good thing - only crap thing is it got me done for speeding on the M2 as i was enjoying myself too much and forgot to look at the speedo! I really love Limbo and Last Blast at the minute, but ask me tommorow and it’ll have changed no doubt!

Posted on Wed, 11 June 2003 at 09:36

#9

Reverend Savage? wrote:

Title: inconsistency

One of the things I like most about T? is their inconsistency.

Because they don’t appear to have been ‘trained’ and are pretty much making it up as they go along, they can hit highs that no other band (for me) can reach. On the other hand the lows are pretty fucking awful. It’s this that makes them so endearing (or infuriating, you decide!)

My opinion is that all of their albums have one (or more) absolute stormer, a few ok’s, and a handful of stinkers.

On the Shameless/HA thing, I think the first half of Shameless is fantastic, but the second half unlistenable. I’d say HA is the better album because there are fewer ‘oh shit, better skip this one’ moment.

Isn’t it good when you can say, about a band who’ve been around this long, that their latest is one of their best?

Posted on Wed, 11 June 2003 at 13:57

#10

Somebody34522432422 wrote:

Title: no

HA and Shameless are very different. HA is sorta like more teenagey (it ain’t really, but that’s the only word I got for it), shameless is pure rock n’ roll and nothing else. Shameless is a better album since all songs have huge melodies and great riffs. The opening track on Shameless is a real killer and those who don’t like it don’t like the true Therapy?. shameless is better than HA.

Posted on Sat, 14 June 2003 at 23:54

#11

hoochalobster (Sarah) Super Moderator wrote:

‘True Therapy?’? I don’t see how anything they’ve done isn’t ‘true’ - it’s all them!

Posted on Sun, 15 June 2003 at 00:06

#12

up_in_flames (Tom) wrote:

Title: Re: no

Quote (author unknown):

[i]those who don’t like it don’t like the true Therapy?. shameless is better than HA.

as I stated somewhere else, opinions are like assholes [some stink and some don’t] the reason why I like this band so much is, that they never recorded the same album again. they never had the same sound again. they never had the same producing style again (despite of chris sheldon). I’m always surprised of what they put out.
Me, beeing a fan (what a terrible word to say) since more than 10 years for now, is asking you: what makes the true t?
if you can tell me, I’ll invite you over to my place and buy you a beer.

cheers ‘I’ve run out of beer’ tom

Posted on Sun, 15 June 2003 at 00:12

#13

Somebody34522432422 wrote:

Title: :)

:)

True Therapy? exists only in your mind. Like you said, I was just stating my opinions and I respect yours :) .

Personally, for me true Therapy? is pure rock n’ roll, here are some songs to help you understand what I mean (these are 100% rocknroll tracks):

He’s Not That Kind Of Girl
Accelerator
Teethgrinder
Opal Mantra (can’t forget that one)
Gimme Back My Brain
Knives (despite the lyrics, lol)
+++++++++++

Basicly, for me it seems that Therapy? has one thing to them. Every one of their albums opens up with a real killer monster track. And that’s what I like, gives you a good feeling when you put the album on play.

Further blessings,
Sparlatacus

Posted on Sun, 15 June 2003 at 00:33

#14

up_in_flames (Tom) wrote:

ok lad, let’s leave this topic alone and let’s be polite again, ok. I will, I promise. See ya!!!

Posted on Sun, 15 June 2003 at 00:41

#15

dano wrote:

I’m growing a mullet. I am rock!

Posted on Sun, 15 June 2003 at 01:04

#16

Citizen Erased wrote:

Don’t do it man! You’ll have to start dating women that don’t shave their pits!

Posted on Sun, 15 June 2003 at 14:59

#17

opalmantra wrote:

It still fascinates me why hairy men-armpits are normal, but not with women. Slurp.

Posted on Sun, 15 June 2003 at 15:02

#18

Citizen Erased wrote:

Hairy woman armpits seemed in profusion on holiday, not pretty.

Not the world’s biggest pube-fan either. If I wanted to floss, I’d buy floss.

Posted on Sun, 15 June 2003 at 15:13

#19

Cringe wrote:

“True Therapy?” is Mr. Andy Cairns babbling on about hippos and elephants at the end of Suicide Pact ;)

WHOOPSY-DAISY! :D

Posted on Mon, 16 June 2003 at 03:22

There are no more replies in this discussion. (Go to the homepage)

to post a reply. Sign in if you’re already a member.

You’re viewing replies 1–19 of 19 by 12 people

·

Page: First | Previous | Next | Last

Other discussions started by Charlie

Title Replies Started Last post
What song is in your head right now ? in Chit-Chat 35 2 Dec 2008
by Charlie		 Yesterday, 18:51
by buffalo-boy
Metallica in Other Bands & Artists 1,423 20 Mar 2003
by Charlie		 28 Nov 2008
by deadsetgav
New Prodigy in Other Bands & Artists 4 27 Nov 2008
by Charlie		 27 Nov 2008
by Charlie
Squall has a new job ! in Chit-Chat 138 13 Oct 2006
by Charlie		 26 Nov 2008
by Taunty Dan
Any Trekkies in ? in Chit-Chat 14 23 Nov 2008
by Charlie		 26 Nov 2008
by Charlie

View all 174 discussions started by Charlie.